AITA for buying my niece two pairs of glasses and letting her get contacts against her dad’s wishes?
My 12-year-old niece needed vision correction, but her dad only sent $100 and told me to buy the cheapest pair possible. I paid for two pairs she loved and a short supply of contacts—and now the whole house is up in arms.
I’m the aunt who steps in when Haley’s parents can’t. They told me to buy the bare minimum, but I wanted her to actually see well and feel good about it—so I paid for two pairs she loved and let her try contacts, and that choice blew up the fragile peace at home.
Haley (12) has four younger step-siblings (two boys, two girls, roughly 5–10). Money is tight; one pair of shoes, reused school supplies, and no new clothes if last year’s still fit. I’m better off financially but don’t hand her dad cash because it gets spread across all five kids. There’s simmering resentment because I reported concerns about the kids being left alone; since then, I keep Haley with me after school and won’t drop her off unless an adult is present. The core friction: I prioritize Haley’s needs when I’m the one taking her, and her dad wants strict “cheapest only” parity.
"They gave me $100 and told me to get the cheapest pair we can find."
At the clinic, Haley asked about contacts, and a same-day fitting was available. I okayed it. She found two frames she genuinely loved, so I said yes to both and later picked up a few boxes of contacts after school. When the glasses arrived, she was thrilled—but her dad was furious. He said she could keep only one pair and that the other glasses and contacts had to stay at my house so she wouldn’t be “rubbing it in” around her step-siblings.
"He told her she gets to keep one pair of glasses and everything else has to stay at my house."
Haley responded by packing most of her things and walking to my place. She’s now refusing to go home. CPS came again, and the younger kids told them Haley “doesn’t live there anymore,” which isn’t helping her dad’s case. He’s demanding that I make her return and stop “spoiling” her, insisting that simply having two pairs visible on her dresser was unfair to the others.
🏠 The Aftermath
Right now, Haley is staying with me and doesn’t want to go back. Her dad is angry and framing the glasses and contacts as the problem.
At his house: one pair allowed, everything else “must stay with me.” At my house: both pairs and the contacts are safe, and I handle pickups. CPS is re-involved after the kids said Haley no longer lives there.
Consequences include renewed CPS scrutiny for her dad and stepmom, tension over fairness with the step-siblings, and a deeper rift between me and her dad about who decides Haley’s needs.
"In a house where everything is scarce, even clear vision became a status symbol."
I’m relieved Haley can finally see well—and also sad that something as basic as vision care sparked a family standoff. The irony is that glasses, a medical need, were treated like luxury decor on a dresser.
.png)
.png)
0 Comments